Armor of Agathys 5e - D&D 5th Edition Spell Book

Classes That Can Cast Armor of Agathys 5e

Surprisingly, the only class in the Player's Handbook that may cast Armor of Agathys is the warlock. Through other game expansions, players may access a sorcerer and paladin subclass, along with the mark of warding dwarf, who may also cast the spell.



Armor of Agathys Spell Effectiveness

Calculations for Healing and Damage

Note that Armor of Agathys only provides temporary hit points, not actual healing. Furthermore, the cold damage dealt by Armor of Agathys only activates so long as the temporary hit points provided by the spell are still active. Finally, note that the DPR (damage per round) provided in the third row is a very rough, estimated calculation of damage, before factoring in the attack's hit chance - in an effort to best provide direct comparison of value.

Armor of Agathys Usefulness

Armor of Agathys 5e is both a temporary healing and damage spell. Players should use Armor of Agathys in the following circumstances:

• Ideally, before any battles begin. Since Armor of Agathys 5e has a 1-hour duration, it's best used before danger shows up, to provide more actions during combat for casting other high-priority spells.
• When fighting enemies with melee attacks. Since Armor of Agathys only deals cold damage to melee attackers, the spell loses half of its value against other spell casters or enemies who attack from a ranged distance.
• Against enemies with cold vulnerability, to maximize damage dealt.
• Against enemies who deal high amounts of damage. Healing after taking damage is a reactive approach to combat, whereas Armor of Agathys 5e proactively increases hit points in anticipation of difficult battles.
• As a way to make a fragile (especially spell caster) character more durable.

Visit the Eternity TTRPG Store!

Combine Armor of Agathys 5e with the Following Spells

Even though Armor of Agathys 5e admittedly has critical limitations to its effectiveness in certain circumstances, it can still be combined with other key spells to considerable effect:

• Bless 5e: the bless spell has limitations of its own, though it does provide provide a +1d4 bonus to saving throws. Basically, since it reduces spell damage, it's useful to have in addition to the temporary hit points provided by armor of agathys.
• Cause Fear 5e: since Armor of Agathys is intended to protect characters during battle, or dissuade enemies from attacking, cause fear can be a great supplement. If cause fear fails or its effect fades, then Armor of Agathys is still in place to help keep characters alive against enemy aggression.
• Charm Person 5e: similarly, charm person may be used to prevent an enemy from attacking. Should the spell fail or its effect end, having a backup defensive spell is always valuable.
• Cure Wounds 5e: if the temporary bonus hit points from armor of agathys get reduced and a character takes damage, having additional healing is always helpful.
• Haste 5e: as with the bless 5e spell, haste provides additional protection in the form of +2AC, doubled movement speed, and advantage on Dexterity saving throws. The extra hit points from armor of agathys can help keep hasted characters alive even longer, particularly against difficult foes. 
• Mage Armor 5e: consider mage armor a lesser version of the haste spell, effectively giving targets +3AC (depending on character builds, etc.). The more hit points a character has - such as from armor of agathys - the more time that bonus AC has to reduce damage taken.

Players should also be aware that temporary hit points cannot stack in DnD 5e. That means spells such as Aid 5e cannot give characters additional hit points, if they're already affected by spells or effects such as armor of agathys 5e.

Armor of Agathys 5e Counters

In all reality, armor of agathys 5e has lots of counters, making it probably a mid-tier spell at best. Though effects like Silence 5e can't be used to directly counter armor of agathys (in most cases) since the spell will probably most often be used prior to battle, there are still other options.

For example, the cold damage from armor of agathys only takes place if the attack that hits them is melee, and before the temporary hit points granted from the effect are depleted. So, if a character with armor of agathys is attacked from range - like with a bow and arrow, or spell - then no cold damage is dealt. Similarly, if melee characters just wait to attack a target who's benefiting from armor of agathys until those temporary hit points are somehow removed, then there's no danger of taking cold damage.

Finally, the biggest "counter" to armor of agathys is to actually deplete the temporary hit points. Consider spells like mage armor, for comparison. Mage armor's bonus to AC doesn't ever go away, at least until the spell's effect ends. So, if the character takes damage, then gets healing, mage armor is still fully in effect. Meanwhile, as soon as 5-damage per spell level is dealt to a character with armor of agathys, the effect fades. Healing doesn't "return" the effect, or provide more value. Basically, it's just about the easiest spell in the game to completely negate.

Armor of Agathys-Type Spells in Eternity TTRPG

I feel like most all great RPGs, whether they're a TTRPG or video game have some kind of frost shell. Which, you can imagine, is basically what comes to mind for me with armor of agathys.

In the Eternity TTRPG Game System - a tabletop game like DnD - there are several spell effects similar to armor of agathys. Below is one such example, which is probably the most similar type of spell.